This blog was written for Worldsupporter.org
The risks of AI explained
While AI can be helpful in many ways, or maybe because AI can be helpful in many ways, more and more people are using the tool for situations in which there’s little room for error.
Recently, AI led a 16-year-old boy into dangerous terrain on Widowmaker Arete in British Columbia, Canada. The teenager asked Claude to plan his trip to Crown Mountain after taking the gondola up Grouse Mountain. Rather than keeping him on a hiking trail, the suggested route took him into steep, technical climbing terrain. Before he knew it, he was stuck and had to be rescued by a mountain rescue team.
This is not the first time something like this has happened. AI has been known to generate non-existent destinations and trails, as well as give incorrect advice on hiking times or the amount of food and water that needs to be brought. This happens because AI cannot directly assess the terrain, weather, or conditions on the ground, let alone the experience and fitness of the person asking. It doesn’t have the practical experience needed to judge how difficult a route might be for an individual hiker, taking into account their experience and abilities. Despite that, the text AI creates can be well-structured, plausible, and convincing. That’s exactly where the problem lies: an answer that sounds confident isn’t necessarily accurate.
There have already been several incidents like the one just mentioned. In September 2026, three novice hikers on Mount Shasta in California became stranded after relying heavily on Google’s Gemini for route and packing advice. What they expected to be an eight-hour climb turned into a multi-day ordeal. They got into trouble during their descent and ended up without sufficient food, water, and shelter.
In the Tatra Mountains in Poland, hikers reportedly used ChatGPT to help plan a route but found themselves stranded in dangerous winter conditions. The suggested route reportedly failed to account for conditions such as icy trails and a severe winter storm. The incident highlights the risks of relying on AI-generated directions without checking local conditions and the suitability of a route.
Tourists in Peru were reportedly directed towards the non-existent “Sacred Canyon of Humantay” after receiving AI-generated travel information. They ended up in a remote area, raising questions about the reliability of AI-generated travel recommendations. You can read more in this article from Mugglehead. Some details of this particular story have been questioned, so it’s worth treating the account with caution.
And in Canada, two hikers got stranded on Unnecessary Mountain (yeah, it’s the real name) after encountering snow while wearing sneakers. They had planned their route with the help of ChatGPT and Google Maps.
And on it goes, with more headlines appearing and rescue organisations calling attention to the topic. In these examples, people’s lives were put at risk, and rescue teams had to come in, sometimes by helicopter. AI-assisted planning isn’t just risking lives; it can also cost people money.
Why AI Isn’t Reliable for Hiking Route Planning
Well, there are many reasons. Let’s start with an example: Google Maps, another tool that can get people into trouble when planning their routes.
Google Maps is one of the most popular route-planning platforms, and it’s great for urban areas, inhabited places, and major roads. It offers options for driving, public transport, cycling, and walking, including hiking in supported areas. Great in many cases, but not necessarily the best tool for planning a challenging mountain hike.
The problem is that Google Maps isn’t designed to provide all the information needed for safe mountain travel. Depending on the location, it may not provide sufficiently detailed topographic information, reliable trail conditions, or enough detail about the difficulty of a particular route.
Just compare Google Maps to a physical topographic map (choose a 1:50,000 or 1:25,000 one) and check the difference in detail. When you know how to read it, a topographic map can help you understand elevation, terrain, and the shape of the landscape, all of which are essential when planning a mountain route. Here’s an example of a hike that went wrong due to Google Maps planning.
Now, when it comes to AI, it’s kind of similar.
AI can draw on a wide range of information and summarise it faster than we can. It’s a great way to get an overview of hiking options and routes, but by no means is it conclusive. AI can draw on a lot of text, but that doesn’t mean it knows what the conditions are like on the ground. It may use outdated or unrelated information, misunderstand a route, or generate information that simply isn’t true.
Another problem is that AI’s answers depend heavily on the questions asked. With a general question like “what do I need to know to hike this mountain?” or “what is the route to peak X?”, you’ll get information AI can find online, presented in a way that sounds convincing. But experienced hikers know that there’s often more to a route than what you can find in a quick online search. A personal anecdote – it once took me 3.5h (including some short breaks) to travel 4.8 km with around 500m of elevation, simply because of the terrain we encountered. Normally I would plan max 1,5 hours for that distance and elevation.
Getting a better understanding of a route requires more detailed questions and knowing which questions to ask. Someone without much hiking experience may not know what to ask in the first place. For example, you need to consider terrain, elevation gain, exposure, weather conditions, daylight, navigation, and escape routes. And even if you ask all the right questions, AI can still make things up, lack relevant information, or rely on unreliable sources. It can present a beautiful, confident trip plan and route that is partly or even totally wrong.
The important distinction here is between using AI to explore your options and using it to make decisions that affect your safety. Asking AI for inspiration for your next hiking destination is one thing. Relying on it to tell you whether a particular mountain route is safe, how to cross a certain river, or whether you can reach the summit before dark is something else entirely.
Even when a route exists and the information about it is correct, that doesn’t automatically mean it’s suitable for you. A trail that is manageable for an experienced hiker in dry summer conditions can become dangerous for a beginner in rain, snow, or poor visibility. A route description also doesn’t necessarily tell you how exposed a path feels, how difficult the terrain is to navigate, or how you’ll cope with it when you’re tired.
How to Plan a Hiking Route Safely Without AI
Planning a hike is something you need to practise, and it takes time to learn. I’m not talking about the often-travelled routes that people walk on a daily basis. I’m talking about more off-the-beaten-track hikes, hikes with significant elevation gain, climbing mountains, or crossing remote territory. But even in more frequently travelled areas, AI can still be wrong.
There are many ways to plan a hike yourself. Using AI is fine for some inspiration, especially when exploring low-risk routes, but when it comes to planning the hike itself, it’s important to do your own research:
- Take a course with a certified instructor to help you get started.
- Research blogs and reviews on hiking apps and websites specific to the area.
- Hiking areas often have websites with specific information regarding trails, trail closures, weather, and current conditions.
- Check hiking and trail apps such as AllTrails, Komoot, and Mapy.com. Don’t blindly pick a trail; read the reviews, too.*
- Get a map and learn how to read it.
- Mark the route on the map. Check the terrain, recognisable points in the landscape, and topography, and double-check your route.
- Set a turnaround time before you leave. Decide when you need to turn back, even if you haven’t reached the summit yet. Check how much daylight you have, allow extra time for unexpected difficulties, and don’t let the desire to reach your destination override your judgement.
- Triple-check your route with people who’ve done it before.
- Also check current conditions such as weather, snowfall, ice, freezing level, cloud cover etc, and cross-check this information.
- Visit the local visitor centre and talk to them about your plans and the current conditions on the mountain. Check the weather forecast and any trail closures shortly before departure, too. Conditions can change quickly, and information you found while planning your hike days or weeks earlier may no longer be accurate.
- Learn what to bring and how to prepare for emergencies.
- Don’t rely on a single navigation tool. When it comes to route-finding, don’t just bring your phone. Always bring a suitable paper map and a compass or dedicated navigation device, and learn how to use them before you leave. Depending on the area, consider carrying a satellite communication or emergency device and a head torch, too. A phone can break, run out of battery, or lose reception, and before you know it, you’re literally and figuratively in the dark.
*Sometimes, even open-source platforms show routes that aren’t real routes or that are very difficult. This can be hard to figure out unless you read reviews and cross-check the information with other people and a map.
The ability to plan a route yourself (and everything that comes with it, like food, water, shelter, etc.) is an essential part of hiking and climbing in the outdoors. It takes practice, but learning these skills can make the difference between a great adventure and a dangerous situation. And, it is also part of the fun and excitement!
My advice: don’t simply trust AI β it has never been there. Do a ton of research before heading off into that unknown adventure. And remember: the greater the consequences of getting something wrong, the more important it is to double-check the information. In the outdoors, that can be the difference between a great adventure and a dangerous situation.
And if your own safety isn’t enough motivation, it could also save you a lot of money.



